Not Snape thats for sure. Meanwhile, other characters, like Harry, try to unmask him. Ultimately though, James rushed into action andmanaged to reach Snape before he could be fully exposed to Lupin. Snape, however, doesn't join the Order in this particular fight against Voldemort at the risk of exposing his cover as a double agent for Dumbledore. Fortunately, Rowling always seems eager to fill in the blanks for her readers. In contrast, his relationship with Lily Potter was quite different. Like the Harry/Hermione love think. http://www.enotes.com/search?q=harry+potter. He'd have been mean to Harry deliberately to prevent anyone from guessing the truth from favouritism then, I guess. Because, in the end, we all make mistakes, we can all act wrongly in certain situations. I think people like your sister, given how you explain it, just haven't read the books and gotten the entire story, so they get confused. Did Snape steal sword? A better question is, why do those who read the book look down and laugh at those who didn't? Next Ron and Hermione, sittin' in a tree. RELATED: Harry Potter: 10 Facts About the Potters Left Out Of The Movies. Several factors combine to give him powerful charisma, from his eerie, snake-like appearance to his merciless attitude to his powerfully compelling ideas and force of will. Finally someone with some sense. "Well Harry Minnie said that you received a post today. Plus, James is even in the movie! The . Following that incident, Severus Snape passed the counterfeit sword to Bellatrix Lestrange. On twitlonger Rowling said that when Snape went to meet with Dumbledore on the windy hilltop he was still a subscriber to the inhuman philosophy of Voldemort. Rowling has shared a number of revelations since the Harry Potter books and films wrapped upincluding the fact that Dumbledore was gay. Dumbledore has been preparing Harry to die at the hands of Voldemort all this time, while Snape has been looking out for him at the risk of his own life. I know for a second I was thinking the same thing but in all the movies & books they say he's a spitting image of James but has his mothers eyes. It has just dawned on me that JK Rowling drops tons of clues during the series that Snape could be Harrys father, not James as we are initially led to believe. Snape showed Albus the doe after he asked Snape if he had developed feelings for Harry. He Calls Lily A Slur. So no harry;s father was definitly not Severus Snape. This thread is archived While Dumbledore trusted him, Harry didnt, and consequently neither did the readers. Next time you read a book and then go see the movie try not going in with preconceived notions (con, I already know what happens doesn't look good on you when you're laughing at others because they don't) and really watch the movie like you've never heard the story before and stop sitting there dictating every line, that's no fun. She also cleared up doubt as to whether Professor Snape held malice against Harry or his father, James Potter. How does fear drive their actions? Look again, the guy doesn't have black hair. During Harry's first year at Hogwarts, the young wizard immediately gets on Snape's bad side, which is likely in large part due to the fact that Harry looks strikingly like his father, James, whom Snape detested during school. They think that Snape is the real father because the whole time he spent odd amount of time watching Harry and making sure he didn't screw up and not just because Dumbledore "Was raising him like a pig for slaughter." Snape died for Harry out of love for Lily. Press J to jump to the feed. In other words, he was the potions genius who's been helping Harry excel at the art of potion-making all year. In the backstory of theHarry Potter franchise, James Potter's rescueofSeverus Snape served as a quietly pivotal momentof the world -- even if neither man was particularly happy about the development, and it only spurred on their longstanding rivalry. In Half-Blood Prince, Harry states that Snape's mother, Eileen Prince, was Pureblood. It seems to me that your sister was trying to read inbetween the lines. After Snape's death, Harry Potter ensured that his portrait remained at Hogwarts, honouring him as a hero, despite their significant personal differences. Despite never appearing in the actual events of either the book or film series, James' rescue of Snape -- although a pretty bad indictment on the kind of person he and his best friends were as teenagers -- is quietly one of the more important momentsin the series' backstory. He was only 21 days older than her. However, if you've read the books or watched the films, you know there's much more to Severus Snape than meets the eye. By using our Services, you agree to our use of cookies. I'm just really confused that they think that way. are you guys really watched the movie? I dont like James and Lily - yes even-though I know we wouldn't have Harry, - he is the only good thing that came from them. Rowling fooled us all, making us believe that Snape was a real villain and that all he wanted was for Harry to suffer. I think people ask that because when you are going through Snapes memories in the last book it just shows how much love he holds for Harrys mother and some people might think that the pure love he shows her translates to love for harry as a father figure but honestly if one of you followed this logic please tell me what I just said because I have no idea. While all of this is going on, Snape's master is seeking out the Elder Wand, the wizarding world's most powerful wand and one of the legendary Deathly Hallows, to make sure he's undefeatable when the time comes to face off against Harry once and for all. It's also why Tonks' patronus had changed into a wolf form in the sixth book, because she loved Lupin. And Albus didn't find it curious that Snape and Lily had the same Patronus because maybe he had realized they were the same person. This relationship will be key to discovering more about Snape as an adult in the Harry Potter saga. Due to the age difference between Rickman and Snape, as he is portrayed in the book, make-up was used on Rickman to make him look younger. Severus Snape's biggest regret. Severus Snape is one of the most intriguing characters in the Harry Potter saga. In fact, being in James' debt was suggested to be something that enraged Snape. He's always had a crush on her even when they started Hogwarts. i think cause snape had a thing for lilly. Something a father would do. He was a double agent, so many character details were kept a secret. What is the summary for Chapter 11 of Harry Potter and the Chamber of Secrets. What J.K Rowling Doesn't Want You To Know About Harry Potter's ParentsSubscribe: http://bit.ly/Subscribe-to-Things DO YOU BELIEVE IN MAGIC | Potterheads: h. No! Maybe a way of coming clean? ". I think the doe petronus shared by Snape and Lily can have another less sinister explanation than Snape is Harry's father. 3 Lord Voldemort. "It is my Hogwarts letter." Harry passed the letter to his mother and was smiling from ear to ear. I guess alot of those who read the book know nothing about movies and how thay make things appear to be something their not and oh yeah EVERY DETAIL is not included in a movie from a book and important details get left out. The scene with Severece's tears in the memory thingy in dumbleweinies' office. They don't replace the diagnosis, advice, or treatment of a professional. Harry Potter: Short Summaries of All the Movies. It's possible his Patronus was also a stag (the only character whose Animagus form and Patronus have both been seen is Professor McGonagall, and hers are both cats). Snape's family lived on Spinner's End, which is shown as a run-down street in "Harry Potter and the Half-Blood Prince," insinuating that Snape's family wasn't very wealthy. Cookies help us bring you Fanpop. Rowling fooled us all, making us believe that Snape was a real villain and that all he wanted was for Harry to suffer. I can see why people who didn't read the books could have somehow jumped to that conclusion. But where do his real loyalties lie? Okay, now I read the books. Snape's adult life at Hogwarts is craftily disguised as a Professor who despises Harry, when in fact Snape loves Harry and has determined, at Dumbledore's request, to save Harry at all costs, including death. Who has ever heard of Severus Potter anyway? Why can't Harry see thestrals before he saw Cedric dying, because he saw his mum dying? Their shared feelings for Lily Evans had only escalated their rivalry, and Snape's impulsive lashing out at Lily over her Muggle-born status strained their relationship. This apparently irrational hatred hides a greater complexity than we could have possibly imagined, turning Severus Snape into a character whose evolution is one of the most significant in the whole saga. Warner Bros. Pictures. When Harry has difficulty shutting off his emotions to practice occlumency, Snape doesn't help anything, and their tension hits a breaking point when Harry inadvertently invades Snape's mind and sees a memory of his father, James, cruelly bullying Snape for no reason. What Would 'Potter' Have Been Like With Tim Roth As Snape? It clearly states that BOTH of Harry's parents are dead. The truth is never as simple as this; the world isnt only made up of good people and bad people there are nuances in between. eNotes.com will help you with any book or any question. I'd imagine if that be the truth then Snape wouldn't treat his son like shit, Who did Harry see in the mirror of Erised? J.K. Rowling stated that Lily Evans may have grown to love Snape romantically if he was not so drawn to the Dark Arts. Can We dream it? That part of the story where we finally understand everything Snape has done, and where we realize why Dumbledore had protected him so much, has become one of the most applauded by fans of the saga. In 2015, Rowling wrote on Pottermore (now Wizarding World) that chemistry, the Muggle equivalent to Potions class, was her least favorite subject in school. Snape was not Harrys father. Dolores Umbridge also casts a Patronus (in the form of a cat) during "Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows.". Suspicions were aroused at every turn by the level of enmity Snape felt toward Harry, but a piece of the puzzle was revealed when readers learned that Snape had a crush on Lilly who had eyes for no one but Harrys father. That's because Snape has always liked Lily since childhood. Instead of accepting her act of kindness, he rejected her and called her a "mudblood" an insult to witches and wizards with Muggle parents despite his own impure bloodline. When he sees his Potter relatives in the Mirror of Erised in the first book, it's narrated that he spots relatives with pretty much every feature he has - even his knobbly knees. well the people that say that are soooo wrong. In his dying moments, Snape asks Harry to look at him clearly a reference to Lily, in that Harry's eyes resemble his mother's and gives him a vial of memories. By using Fanpop, you agree to our use of cookies. Harry Potter creator J.K. Rowling poses for photographers in central London, on June 23, 2011. As Rowling sees it, Snape eventually sacrificed himself in order to save Harry at the Battle of Hogwarts, so Harry felt the need to honor him. Professor Slughorn, his Potions Master, was very fond of both Snape and Lily, so they were both likely a part of his elite student group, the Slug Club. But his surname also holds ancestral significance in England, where it's tied to families who lived near the snp (boggy land) in North Yorkshire, the Lowlands, and Suffolk. What seemed to be a childrens story has now become a dark and nuanced one. In the books though, Harry is described as strongly resembling James (the only differences are eye colour and scar) while he and Snape only have black hair in common really. It's just a fact. Though Harry believes that Sirius James and Lily's best friend sold them out to Voldemort, the truth is that Peter Pettigrew, who was friends with all three, actually betrayed James and Lily and worked for Voldemort. I am wondering the same thing about Snape being Harry's father after watching all of the movies, and even after reading everyone's response about this idea being ludicrous. Fury of the Gods Special: Shazamily Matters, 25 Years Ago, Michelle Yeoh Starred in James Bond's Most Underrated Movie, 10 Worst Written Female Characters In An Action Movie. And that's whenSnape shows up and does the job himself. As the series progresses, Snape's character becomes more layered and enigmatic. No. Harry is Snape's father Just read a fic where Harry got thrown back in time and fell in love with Eileen Prince and fathered Snape. However, when Snape eavesdrops on Dumbledore'smeeting with Sybill Trelawney, who prophecies Voldemort's fall at Harry's hands, he begs Dumbledore to save Lily, James, and Harry at any cost, promising anything in return though this comes after Snape asks Voldemort to spare only Lily, disgusting Dumbledore. In the horrible aftermath, Dumbledore convinces Snape that the only way to show his love to Lily is to protect Harry, the only part of her that survives, and make sure that her death and her sacrifice to save Harry's life won't be in vain, especially when Voldemort resurfaces to attack Harry. In the book, we learn that James Potter and his friends were bullying Snape, and Lily came to his defense. Not this shit again! eNotes Editorial, 7 Nov. 2011, https://www.enotes.com/homework-help/is-severus-snape-really-harry-s-dad-292620. In theHarry Potter series, Severus Snape is long established as one of Harry's most consistent antagonists. Harry inherited the stag form from James. Jemes is light and Snape is black like Harry is. Anyways, they did meat again. It's likely however that he learned the truth following Voldemort's rebirth as he showed much less hostility towards Sirius than before (while still a significant amount) and he was made aware that Peter was alive and on the side of the Death Eaters. No! Harry Potter named his son after the character Professor Severus Snape in tribute to him dying for for Harry out of love for Lily [Potter],JK Rowling revealed on Friday. Her reply ignited a huge debate among Twitters legion of Harry Potter fans, prompting Rowling to tell them to never change.. J. K. Rowlings, author of the Harry Potter series, went to a great deal of trouble creating unique characters who shared common connections. She said, flat-out, that Harry resembled no one in his family - and that he had "thick, messy black hair.". Snape as the father of Harry! In Order of the Phoenix, Sirius mentions that all Pureblo. He also learns that Snape's doe Patronus, after Lily's own Patronus, appeared to Harry in the woods and guided him towards Gryffindor's sword. Born to Muggle Tobias Snape and witch Ellen Prince, young Severus Snape has a difficult childhood due to a strained and often angry relationship between his parents, which Harry personally witnesses when he accidentally glimpses one of Snape's private childhood memories. Throughout the Harry Potter series, the Dursleys treat Harry very cruelly in regards to his magic. He mightve said "you're just like you're swine of a father" but when I heard that he said father as if in inverted commas. Were drip-fed with information about his past bit by bit. As readers or viewers, were surprised that no one besides Harry and his friends is aware of Snapes evil. There's a whole essay in why Harry gave his son Snape's name, but the decision goes to the heart of who Harry was, post-war. I Saw People Saying That on Tumblr before I Saw or even Read The Final Book, So That was a Shock. In the books, Snape is one of the youngest teachers to be recruited at Hogwarts school. I wish Snape was his father becuase I dont like James. Latest answer posted October 26, 2018 at 8:07:12 AM. In The Deathly Hallows, the last book in the saga, we realize that there are no longer any people who we could classify as good or bad. Having taught at Hogwarts for fourteen years in. The D answers by saying its not curious at all. How does Harry change throughout the second book, Harry Potter and the Chamber of Secrets? I typed in "When Harry finds out" And the search engine top result was "When Harry finds out Snape is his father" Thank goodness it was wrong Ok, Snape was a death eater and if the death eaters and voldermont were the people who killed Harry's mum and dad why would snape help kill his wife and attempt to help voldermont kill harry obvioulsly guys THINK, I happen to know exactly how you feel since my DAD and sister feel that snape is the real father. In The Chamber Of Secrets, I'm pretty sure that it says that Harry looks nothing like the Dursleys, or nothing like his surviving family, not that he resembles no one in his family. Thus, were faced with the question: Who really is who in Harry Potter? i think people got confused bc they gave alot of details on how snape and lily were really close friends and snape really did love her. That would have been a brilliant twist! He named Albus Severus because he admired Snape's courage in spying, and possibly felt guilty for having doubted and hated the man throughout his life. It has just dawned on me that JK Rowling drops tons of clues during the series that Snape could be Harry's father, not James as we are initially led to believe. We see James as the leader of his group, the popular joker whos always looking for trouble. Because the movies leave out more than half the details from the books. Snape begs Dumbledore never to tell anybody that he's protecting Harry, and the heartbroken wizard agrees to the painful task. She is the daughter of Severus Snape and Lily Evans, who later . He turned out to be more of a good guy than fans initially thought, and his somewhat sticky past with Harry's father was revealed which did not paint James in a good light at all. Now Voldemort's apparent right-hand man, Snape is named the new headmaster of Hogwarts, which puts him in the perfect position to silently help Harry with the aid of Dumbledore's moving portrait, painted after his death. If you look at the etymology of the words, you'll see he's both referencing Lily and his vow to . However she took that knowledge to her grave. Throughoutseven novels -- in turn, adapted into eight films --Harry Potterrevealed details about multiple eras of the Wizarding World. They do both wear glasses. after the character's death. Of course, when Sirius eventually escapes, Snape is livid, creating even more tension between him and Harry. He was also a former Death Eater. Rowling plays around with the questions in our minds. The films give the impression that Snape grew up alongside Lily and her sister, Petunia. 2006-2023 Fanpop, Inc., all rights reserved. And, perhaps, one of the characters that best embodies the duality of human nature is Severus Snape the heartbroken man who built a shell to hide his true goodness. Harry's real father is James Potter, and this has been consistent from the first book to the last, and even in all the films. His mother was a witch and his father was a Muggle, leading to the moniker "The Half-Blood Prince." The Snape that we get to know in the saga shows himself as a dark, cold, and frustrated man professionally, and probably also personally. At the Sorting Ceremony, Lily is sorted into Gryffindor, while Snape ends up in Slytherin, ensuring that the two friends are separated for their entire tenure at Hogwarts. Voldemort might not be the dark wizard we thought he was as we see glimpses of his slightly happier childhood. And that when he agrees to protect Harry he says no one can know. For example, Harry spends literally the entirety of book 6 relating to and identifying with the Half-Blood Prince. It appears that he also played his part very well. I'm not sure where people have got that idea. BOOM, People obviously don't pay enough attention and they are lost in the moment of the realisation of snape actually being a pretty good guy, because at first I felt the same way too, People think Snape is Harry Potter's father even though James Potter is Harry's because Dumbledore said "Make sure Harry is safe and pretend that you're is his father.". After giving his life to defeat Voldemort, Harry is able to return to the realm of the living and face Voldemort one last time, and as the true master of the Elder Wand, he brings the Dark Lord down for good. 2023 Minute Media - All Rights Reserved. No one ever asked that question, but I knew right off the bat that he wasn't his dad. Rowling described him in one 2015 tweet as "grey," with both saint-like and devil-like tendencies. The reason Snape was protecting Harry, and the truth he didn't want anyone to know, is that he loved Lily and he felt guilty about his role in her death - it'd been him who'd overheard the prophecy and reported that to Voldemort. One fan asked about what Snape smells like, and although the original tweet with the question has since been deleted, Rowling's reply is still up. It's nearly impossible to think of any actor other than Alan Rickman playing Snape, but he almost didn't. However, Snape was truly a part of the Order of the Phoenix and . Despite his status as a Death Eater as well as implications that he had some form of status among them before Voldemort's attack on the Potters, Snape did not seem to be aware of Peter Pettigrew's role in the Death Eaters nor was he aware that Peter was actually the one who betrayed Lily to Voldemort as he seemed sure that Sirius Black was the culprit. I'm honestly tired of hearing the theory that Snape is Harry's "real dad" because if he was really Snapes son then WHYYYY Was literally never attracted to Snape, and why does Harry have ALMOST ALLLL of James' physical features INCLUDING hair, height, eye wear, and physical body type other than the fact that he was raised on very little food. Severus and Lily were also close in age. A new professor at the school, Lupin's presence escalates the anger felt by Snapetoward the past. go to, It can happen, but its rare and always seems tied to tragic or unrequited love. Harry Potter fandom is one of the largest, most active and productive in the world. Who asks this kind of question? James Potter who is good in quidditch. For example, why is Draco Malfoy acting weirder than normal? The shared doe patronus meant that Snape had loved Lily. In the books, the resemblance between James and Harry is pretty much stuffed down our throats, but it isn't possible to find two unrelated actors who'd be that similar. 2023 TIME USA, LLC. 3. This connection largely carries over to the films and goes a long way toward explaining the inherent hate Snape seems to have for Harry. Severus is also forced to wear mismatched clothes, suggesting he may have been neglected by his parents. In Harry's fifth year, now that Voldemort has officially returned, it's more important than ever for "the Boy Who Lived" to protect himself against the Dark Lord, who's skilled in the art of legilimency (meaning that he can delve into Harry's thoughts at any time). Rupert Grint admitted to being afraid of him in an interview. For this reason, its a much bigger surprise when we discover the truth. My dad just asked me this same question.. But he saves most of his venom for Harry, whom he punishes especially harshly. Why did Uncle Vernon lock Harry in his room inHarry Potter and the Chamber of Secrets? Since his happiest and most loving memories were with Harry's mother, Lily, his Patronus took the same form as hers which is what made Harry follow it in the first place. Does this make Dumbledore a bad guy and Snape a hero? Even just from his name, Snape, it sounds like snake, usually associated with evil. Let me just end these questions right know James POTTER not Servus SNAPE. In honouring Snape, Harry hoped in his heart that he too would be forgiven. H arry Potter named his son after the character Professor Severus Snape in tribute to him dying for "for Harry out of love for Lily [Potter],"JK Rowling revealed on Friday. The Harry Potter novelist shed light on Twitter over the epilogue to Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows, which revealed that Harry named his son Albus Severus. You can't make him a devil: he died to save the wizarding world. Snape waves his wand producing his potronus and it's the same as Lillies. But maybe when Voldemort kills Snape, and he gives the teardrop to Harry, maybe that confused her or something. Snapes dual nature has been present throughout the saga. Hate him. A Member of Townsquare Entertainment News. In 2007, when asked by a fan . By accepting all cookies, you agree to our use of cookies to deliver and maintain our services and site, improve the quality of Reddit, personalize Reddit content and advertising, and measure the effectiveness of advertising. Though Snape begs for her forgiveness, particularly because Lily was defending him against James, he can't justify hurting Lily, and she gives up on him for good. J. K. Rowlings, author of the Harry Potter series, went to a great deal of trouble creating unique characters who shared. Severus Snape is not Harrys father. " Thank you" Snape said. The only thing making James and Harry look alike is the glasses and hair (plus they're just actors anyway). Snape takes out all his past frustration on Harry, whom he sees as a reflection of his father and, consequently, as an enemy and rival. For example, we see a teenage Severus Snape being bullied by James Potter, Harrys father. A patronus can just change to reflect someone else's patronus due to a tragic or unrequited love. Rowling demystifies, in part, the heroism of Harrys father. When we came out of the theatre my sister was wide eyed and shocked I felt proud that I read the books and she didnt because she looked confused so I told her in the I-read-the-book-and-you-didnt tone "Al right Alice what is it that got you confused from the movie I can answer ANYTHING.." she turned to me and said: "One question: Is Snape Harry's REAL father" I just wanted to slap her when I heard that question and its not just her my friends asked me THE SAME THING.